GREEN BAY, WI (WTAQ) - A Brown County judge is ordering that some information about the lead investigator of the 1992 murder of Tom Monfils be turned over before a hearing next week.
During a motions hearing Wednesday, Judge James Bayorgeon ruled that all available court, legal and public records in the murder case be turned over.
64-year-old Keith Kutska, one of six men convicted of the murder, is seeking a new trial. Kutska claims that Monfils committed suicide.
Monfils disappeared while working at the then-James River paper mill in Green Bay. The facility is now the Georgia-Pacific Day Street mill.
Monfils' body was found 2 days later at the bottom of a two-story pulp vat, with a rope tied around his neck and a 40-pound weight at the other end.
Attorneys for Kutska subpoenaed former investigator Randy Winkler to produce items relating to his, “mental, emotional, psychological, and/or psychiatric condition, illness and/or condition that (Winkler) experienced at any time between 1992 and 1997, including any treatment.” Information about any psychological disability payments Winkler may have received from the city were also requested.
In court, Winkler's attorney argued that what was requested of his client and his own law firm was, "privileged, too broad and burdensome."
Judge Bayorgeon, who presided over the original trial, agreed the subpoenas were too broad. However, Bayorgeon ordered Winkler provide any documents in his possession, relating to his mental condition that were presented in any judicial or administrative hearing, like worker's compensation.
Winkler's attorney Bruce Bachhuber must do the same, but as it pertains to exhibits presented in federal court.
The motions hearing was set ahead of the July 8-10 evidentiary hearing, as Winkler will be out of state during that time.
Kutska, along with Rey Moore, Michael Hirn, Dale Basten, Michael Piaskowski and Michael Johnson, was sentenced to life in prison for the murder. Piaskowski’s conviction was later overturned by a federal judge and released.
(Additional reporting from FOX 11).